September 2 2022 | 7 Min Read

Gain advantage with a supply chain center of gravity analysis

Posted By
Lynne Vogl
Share
Gain advantage with a supply chain center of gravity analysis
Picture two rival paper manufacturing companies. They’re based in the same city. Both businesses have a nationwide customer base. They’re roughly the same size. Each company has invested in a solid suite of transportation management tools to ensure its freight outlay is as cost-efficient as organizationally possible.
Company A is thriving while company B is barely scraping a profit.

There’s one critical difference between our hypothetical enterprises. Thanks to a strategically placed distribution center, company A can ship its products efficiently to its most critical customers. Customer B, meanwhile, is fighting a supply chain war of attrition against steep carrier rates, reduced delivery reliability, and slower delivery times.

Company A’s secret weapon was a freight operation that leveraged its supply chain’s center of gravity (COG).

Supply chain center of gravity analysis

A COG analysis identifies the optimal locations for one or more distribution centers. Drawing from a large dataset – typically comprising physical customer location, shipment count, weight and cost, carrier data, and freight type – a COG analysis builds up a detailed picture of distribution efficiency across your whole supply chain. From there, the analysis can extrapolate optimal points of distribution. By building your supply chain around optimal distribution points, you can lower your freight costs, improve delivery reliability and, in some instances, even extend your reach to new markets.

Let’s take a look inside a COG analysis IL2000 conducted for one client.

COG Figure1Figure 1.


Take a moment to familiarize yourself with the main moving parts of a COG analysis:

  • Pane A displays a map of customer locations, color-coded by region.
  • Panes B and C present these same customer data points, with the X axis plotting latitude and longitude respectively and the Y axis plotting shipment weight. The size of the data point indicates the total order count; more on that later.
  • Panes D and E filter the data by type of shipment and location.
  • And finally, (and here’s where the money’s at) pane F reveals an optimal distribution location.

Behind the pretty graphics

Before we get to some use cases, there are a few features worthy of note here.

  1. Every analysis builds on a large dataset: You just can’t perform a meaningful COG analysis on the back of an envelope. To accurately arrive at that one dot you see in pane F, our BI team will typically analyze thousands of data points.

  2. Results can be counterintuitive: Be prepared to be surprised. You might assume you can look at a cluster of points on a map and gain an instant “gut feel” for an optimal distribution point. Instinct leads people astray in an analysis like this because you’re looking at locations on a map and remembering total shipment counts. The critical factors in a COG analysis, weight and shipment cost, are far more difficult to intuit.

  3. There is no single “correct” result: Something you can’t ascertain from this graphic alone is the process that drives it. A COG analysis is typically highly interactive. Over the course of several sessions, we’ll slice your dataset up in different ways to identify several optimal location points, determined by everything from raw revenue to your growth strategy. Finding a final optimal distribution point, from a process standpoint, is like peeling back the layers of an onion.

Check out this case study for a hands-on example of how A COG analysis untangled one client’s shipping complexities.

COG analysis use cases

When might you consider working with IL2000 to perform a COG analysis on your supply chain?

Taming supply chain complexity

The further something has to travel, the more impact the weight of a shipment will have on its cost. But it isn’t that simple. Some regions are harder to reach. Some clients order in smaller weight units. Here’s a real-life example. Take a closer look at the two circled data points in Figure 2. Both points are similarly placed on the Y axis, meaning the client ships a similar weight of product to these customers. However, the blue company data point is much larger, meaning it has a much higher order count. Now, multiply the impact of these small but significant nuances across your whole supply chain. It’s close to impossible to weight these correctly without a COG analysis.

COG Figure2Figure 2.

Compensating for your logistics outliers

Nothing in life is perfect. With close enough examination, even the empirical impeccability of data can fall short of perfection. Outliers can create significant “turbulence” in a dataset. Figure 3 reveals a few of the more obvious outliers you may encounter. Your business may have an out-of-the-way customer location. Or you may have one customer who made an unusually large order, throwing off the accuracy of your dataset at a particular point in time. A COG analysis offers a data-driven approach to identifying and accommodating for these and a host of similar problematic data points.

COG Figure3Figure 3.

Exploring and comparing scenarios

Your supply chain’s optimal distribution location depends on what you want to achieve. The interactive nature of a COG analysis allows you to gain deeper clarity on how different distribution locations impact your business model. Let’s take Figure 4 as an example and assume this client plans to develop a second distribution point. In the next 12 months, this client plans to expand into the midwestern market. The company also plans to launch a new kind of product, for which consumer demand is significantly higher on the West coast. Using a COG methodology, we can analyze these scenarios separately. We can explore optimal distribution points for two geographical areas (likely pointing to somewhere in circle A). We can also ascertain where this company should distribute from for a product exclusively catering to one segment of its customers (in this case, somewhere in zone B). A COG analysis allows you to link your supply chain decisions to how you want your company to grow.

COG Figure4Figure 4.

The unbearable weight of being (in the wrong place)

Your supply chain is far more likely to founder if it’s weighed down by a suboptimal point of distribution. At the least, you’ll need to deal with higher freight costs, slower delivery times, and greater uncertainty. Choosing a better place from which to distribute is a critical decision, one that should be driven by hard data and expert analysis.

X marks the spot. Find it!

Talk to IL2000 about having a center of gravity analysis conducted for your supply chain. We can help you weigh your options and guide you to a smart decision.

 

Topics: Distributor, Freight Costs, Business Intelligence

Related Posts

ManoByte

How we help businesses ship difficult products

Construction materials that are hard to move and require special handling pose unique supply chain...
Read More
ManoByte

Freight classification for LTL

What you should know about freight classification and why it’s important.

If LTL shipping is even a...

Read More